Sharingan vs Mystic eyes of Death Perception

[Absulute Newtype]

Sharingan
MS or not

who's eyes will win in an combat situation?

[Houzukimaru]

when u make a matchup u should really give some info about each side

at least what manga/anime theyre from

[Absulute Newtype]

The eyes are not really different set of eyes but are a circuit (possibly similar to a Magic Circuit) that opens up in the users brain and normal eyes, allowing them to "perceive death" in the form of lines and dots. The user in question is the only one who can touch or use these lines and dots (i.e. no one can interact with the lines/dots even if the user of the eyes were to point out their location on something).

These lines can then be traced with a sharp object such as a knife or a sword. Cutting the line “breaks” the object along that line and damage inflicted this way can not be healed or repaired in any way. Healing is possible if cutting the line doesn't completely separate a part of the object from the object itself.


Dots can be pierced by sharp objects. Piercing a dot effectively “erases” that object from existence, in a sense that the object loses even it's inherent properties such as momentum, toxicity, and generally any effect it may impose on it's surrounding. Living things whose dot was pierced get “stopped” and, as a consequence, die. While this death may not be instant, it is absolutely permanent, and can't be reversed or bypassed, even by reincarnation.

Tohno/Nanaya Shiki: Possesses the ability to perceive the death of not merely life but the underlying existence of anything physical. In this case, the eyes can be used to annihilate the "existence" of the object. When applied to a living person's body, it doesn't directly "kill them" but rather "annihilates their existence" and because something that doesn't exist cannot live, the world will correct the contradiction and bring "death" to the nonexistent person. In this way, Tohno/Nanaya Shiki's eyes and Tohno Shiki (Roa)'s use of their eyes can be viewed as ultimately different: While Tohno Shiki (Roa) can only kill "life" and bring it "death," Tohno/Nanaya Shiki can kill the "existence," which, if applied to a living object, will consequently result in a "life" "dying."

Ryogi Shiki: Possesses the ability to to perceive the death of life force and also the death of the existence of objects and concepts alike. At this level, it enables her to perceive and annihilate physical material, persons, diseases, ghosts, intentions, and even magecraft.

[Houzukimaru]

after reading that id have to say Sharingan but only if its MS

it seems like they have to look at their opponent to be able to see and cut those dots and lines and someone with a MS could just trap them in Tsukiyomi as soon as they do

but other than wat is said there i dont know anything about these mystical eyes so i might be interpriting their abilies wrong

[Absulute Newtype]

if you want to know watch the lunar legend tsukihime